Reading Between the Lines

by Hal Bennett on 05.14.2010

46 Responses

It’s a good thing Nia remembered to go check out the bookstore like Madame Zee said! Apparently I forgot to tell her about it in the first place—and I know I got off easy about that, because it’s, um, not exactly pretty when she gets mad—but it looks like, thanks to you guys, we may have uncovered something pretty interesting!

You guys seem to think the postcard and the book are connected, and we agree. So, we started flipping through the book looking for other clues, as emilys861 and luna*zeus suggested.

We found some pretty cool stuff! Tiffany923 told us to look in the margins for notes, and we found plenty. Scribbled along the sides were personal comments, like, “I once helped Nanna Dot build a scarecrow” and “This scene reminds me of that song, ‘Hit the Road, Jack!’” One page even had a recipe for apple turnovers (huh?)! But the most random thing was that the notes were in three totally different handwriting styles as if they were written by three different people. One of them matched the handwriting in the inscription—very old fashioned, too. It was faded like it was written a long time ago—not like Amanda’s writing at all.

As for the message, the name “Meg” definitely rang a bell, and after emilys861, invisible, _Sakura_, and stef_stone brought up the postcard Amanda left for us, we fished it out and had another look at it. As you guys may remember, on the front is a scene from the movie version of the Wizard of Oz, and on the back is the note, “Meg knew she had to search. Think about IT. –M”. The first time we saw the note we were baffled, but eventually, we pieced together the meaning. Or at least we think so.

This is how Callie describes that day:

“Wait a second!” She dashed out of the room and almost before she was gone, she was back, carrying a book. “Meg. It. IT.” She looked fro me to Hal. “Don’t you get it?”

I still had no idea what she was talking about, but Hal was smiling. “Nia, you’re a genius.”

She shot him a flirtatious grin. “I know.”

“Okay, would one of you geniuses mind filling me in here?”

Nia held up the book so I could see the title. “A Wrinkle in Time,” I read off the cover. “By Madeleine L’Engle.”

“Which is what the M is for,” Nia explained. “Before the card got ripped, it must have said Madeleine L’Engle.”

When neither she nor Hal elaborated, I said, “And…”

Nia flipped through to the end of the book. “Meg and her brother go to search for their missing father. He’s being held hostage by this enormous brain on an alien planet.”

“Um, you’re saying Amanda’s being held hostage by an enormous brain on another planet and she wants us to search for her?” Was I the only one who found this interpretation of her note just a little ridiculous?

Nia looked up from the book. “You’re kidding, right? I mean, tell me you can see that you’re being just a tad literal.”

“But it is a message that we’re supposed to search for her,” said Hal. “I’m sure of it. Follow the yellow brick road. Think about IT. Meg knew she had to search. All signs point to Amanda wanting us to look for her. I can’t believe I didn’t figure it out earlier.”

Stef Stone had the good idea to check out some other Megs, like maybe the Meg in Inkheart (love that book), which we should definitely do. Research is excellent. And I am sure we all have those books on our shelves, or can get to some.

But I’m kind of going with this idea: if the Meg in the inscription is the same Meg from the postcard, then who is the IT? The first time I read that message I got chills up my spine. Of course we aren’t dealing with an alien planet bent on mind control, as Nia pointed out, but there is definitely something weird going on.

Metaphorically speaking, could there be an IT in Orion?

46 responses

  1. AllieK

    There could be.  Here’s something I found on wikipedia on IT


    IT is the bodiless telepathic brain that dominates the planet of Camazotz. IT controls all the people in Camazotz and makes people often do same things together in a mechanistic synchronicity as if they were robots. IT speaks through The Man With Red Eyes and later through Charles Wallace, and is functionally part of the interstellar cloud of evil called the Black Thing. IT is described as slightly larger than a human brain. Housed near the “CENTRAL Central Intelligence” building, IT is said to pulse and quiver on IT’s dais. IT’s aim is to enforce absolute conformity on Camazotz, with the claimed benefit of eliminating war, unhappiness and inefficiency. However, IT is aware of cruelty, referring to “ITself” as “the Happiest Sadist”.

    So if there’s an IT in Orion, its someone whos somehow controlling everyone to conform or soemthing.  I can’t think of anyone who’s trying to do that.  Maybe its person who could be after Amanda and Callie’s mom? I’m not sure exactly who it could be, but I know Amanda was practically the opposite of conformity

    Its interesting that the handwriting was in three different handwriting styles too. Obviously three different people were writing in it. Maybe there’s another trio of guides, from the past or something?

    • Ollie

      This is great news! Now were a little bit closer to finding something out! Whether it be something big or small, it will help us in the end to uncover the mystery of Amanda!
      -Ollie

      • KassidyAnn

        That’s totally far fetched, (no offense intended) Do you have a college in Orian? I once heard of a school with the initials IT. Just a thought…

        • KassidyAnn

          Sorry Ollie. I was talking about AllieK’s post, not yours.

          • Ollie

            Hey i just had an idea! What if we should also be looking at the letters in the corner of the postcard and the year: MGM 1939. What if something happened in Orion in 1939 that had to do with MGM, whether it’s the initials of a person or the first initial of three different people. Maybe it even has to do with a business or something! Maybe it’s not in Orion though, maybe its in a different state or even in a different country! Maybe, just maybe, in Amanda’s lies she gave you about her life and family she was giving you a clue about the postcard and where to look for the event that took place!!!
            -Ollie

            • RRRules

              We need to do a handwriting analysis. I’m useless in this area. Can you do it, Hal?
              Thanks for that AllieK.
              Maybe the Black Thing (the “interstellar cloud of evil”) is referring to an actual storm? I was just checking the weather, and there’s going to be a massive thunderstorm in Orion sometime this week. Lots of black clouds…
              The red eye thing gave me a little idea, too. Some people are born with red eyes. Albinos. Sometimes they’re complete albinos, fully colorless, and others just have albinism (is that a word?) in their eyes, resulting in red eye. Any albinos in Orion?

              • fashionista17

                To answer the question, well, I’m not sure about it.

                • trumpetgirl

                  By the way Ollie, the MGM 1939 is referring to the year one of the [many] wizard of oz movies came out. MGM (metro goldwyn mayer) is the company with the lion that roars before every movie, (lion sound familiar, the cover of the book with a lion on it? Probably nothing but still).

                  Maybe the IT is the Braggs…they have lots of power and money (I’m just trying to make connections here). Remember in the book it talked about how ‘free’ Heidi was in school (free to do almost anything she wanted of course) just because her parents told the school to or something like that. And that is just one of the many examples of how much power the Bragg family has (hospital wing dedicated to them ring a bell?)

                  • Ollie

                    I know, i was just saying that maybe there was another message to it, that is has some- any type of meaning that could somehow help

                    • RRRules

                      Wait. Wasn’t ‘39 the year the yellow stone necklace thing was donated by E. Lear for Gemma Valentino?

                      • Ollie

                        Hmmm, maybe! See thats a start! I’ll go try to check and then post what i find.

                        • Ollie

                          Yellow star sapphire was purchased from Edward Lear
                          (kind of sounds like Leary but that might just be me).
                          I also remembered the initials MGM
                          It’s in the Museum’s rare Gemstone and Mineral collection!
                          Ta-da! MGM!
                          I Couldn’t find any information about the years this happened though.
                          Maybe Cornelia can help us out with that.

                          -Ollie

                          • Jess☮❥

                            [“I once helped Nanna Dot build a scarecrow” and “This scene reminds me of that song, ‘Hit the Road, Jack!’” One page even had a recipe for apple turnovers (huh?)!]

                            Obviously, this is tied to Amanda’s wallpaper (the Wizard of Oz one). Scarecrow is pretty self-explanatory and “Hit the Road, Jack!”.... Well, THE YELLOW BRICK ROAD!!

                            Now if we only knew what turnips meant…

                            • Pipper

                              Following AllieK,  maybe Amanda has made a totally different person up, and you should look for oppisite amandas(if that make sense…)
                              Or, maybe Amanda is saying not to LOOK for her, but to look OUT for other people and that will somehow end you up saying “OMG where have you been?” to Amanda when you see her.

                              • tiffany923

                                IT is probably like AllieK suggested something that tries to control everything in Orion. Hmmm, who could that be? Maybe Mr. Braggs? Does anyone know if he is controlling?

                                • SerenaRules

                                  Maybe the other inscriptions hold clues to who or what IT is. Look at the people that last checked the book out.

                                  • Jess☮❥

                                    Have you guys ever thought that maybe IT isn’t exactly something that’s controlling Orion? Sometimes the hardest clues have the easiest solutions.

                                    My guess:
                                    IT stands for something like ASAP stands for As Soon As Possible.

                                    • Ollie

                                      maybe if IT stands for something like you said Jess
                                      maybe IT stands for “In Time”

                                      -Ollie

                                      • iFRENCHFRyy

                                        You may be right, Ollie, but it doesn’t really seem to make sense.

                                        “Meg knew she had to search. Think about ‘IN TIME’.”

                                        That is, unless she’s talking about actually thinking IN TIME; as in, thinking a certain time of day? Kind of like how all three of them ended up being on top of that hill on Midnight. It has to be connected to a certain time of day, right?

                                        Then again, I might be wrong.

                                        • Jess☮❥

                                          In Time… In Time… Hmm… Oh wait! I think I got it!

                                          In Time as in A Wrinkle IN TIME by Madeleine L’Engle!

                                          The postcard said “Meg knew she had to search. Think about ‘IT’(which we think might be “In Time”).” Maybe she’s saying “Think about the book”?

                                          I’m not sure exactly what it means and if it’s any help at all, but it’s something.

                                          • marycaulf

                                            Yes!!!!!

                                            • trumpetgirl

                                              I still think that the trio should look at the oldest copy of a wrinkle in time that the library has… it’s probably a clue!

                                              IT…IT…I like the in time idea, and it’s really the only thing that works here. Maybe by saying “Meg knew she had to search. Think about [a wrinkle] in time” Madeleine L’Engle is saying remember what happenend in that book.

                                              Also, who would Madeleine L’Engle write a postcard to about this? Amanda? Maybe Amanda just wrote it and wripped off the corner so you would think it was Madeleine L’Engle, another refrence to A Wrinkle in Time?

                                              • Jess☮❥

                                                trumpetgirl, you might be on to something. Has anyone read A Wrinkle in Time and knows what happens in it?

                                                • ♥MLE♥

                                                  K so I have read the book. And I found a bibloagraphy on it… here it is..:
                                                  “Meg Murry, her little brother Charles Wallace, and their mother are having a midnight snack on a dark and stormy night when an unearthly stranger appears at their door. She claims to have been blown off course, and goes on to tell them that there is such a thing as a “tesseract,” which, if you didn’t know, is a wrinkle in time.

                                                  Meg’s father had been experimenting with time-travel when he suddenly disappeared. Will Meg, Charles Wallace, and their friend Calvin outwit the forces of evil as they search through space for their father?”

                                                  Now there are many similarities to Amanda and Meg as you can all see. The book talks about the IT which happens to have taken thier father because he can time travel at the end IT is destroyed with light, i believe, if i am wrong someone correct me :P. Well the thing is really that Amanda might be saying that there is an IT amoung us that needs to be destroyed by a person who is ‘light”. There could also be a hint towards why Amanda has dissapeared. That the IT has taken her and she needs “light” aka totems? Like Nia, Hal, and Callie to come find her. There is a lot of possiblilties with the reference to the books. I think thats because the books were so full of information, the postcard could be anything.
                                                  (BTW if you got bored of my really long post, sorry ^_^)

                                                  • SarahB

                                                    Perhaps the IT is what Amanda and Callie’s mom are both running from. The IT is the thing that they (Amanda and whoever) asked Thornhill to help save them from.

                                                    • RRRules

                                                      Ooh. O_o.
                                                      “Think about a wrinkle in time”!

                                                      Also: Good job Ollie. MGM=Museum Gem Collection! Anyone see the conenction? E Lear doante in 1939 to the MGM?

                                                      Also: Jess brought up turnips. Well, if you’ve read Dianna Wynn Jones, you may have heard of Howl’s Moving Castle. In the book (and movie) there’s a character named “Turniphead” who is actually some sort of scarecrow (well, with a turniphead). Anyone?

                                                      • Jess☮❥

                                                        RRRules—now that you mention it, I do remember seeing that movie. Turniphead was a scarecrow. How does he tie into this clue, though?

                                                        • Jess☮❥

                                                          [“I once helped Nanna Dot build a scarecrow” and “This scene reminds me of that song, ‘Hit the Road, Jack!’” One page even had a recipe for apple turnovers (huh?)!]

                                                          Guys, I just discovered something that I think y’all need to hear.

                                                          Okay, so obviously, “I once helped Nanna Dot build a scarecrow” is referring to the scarecrow in the Wizard of Oz. “This scene reminds me of ‘Hit the Road, Jack!’ ” refers to the yellow brick road. But where do apple turnovers tie in?

                                                          I googled “Were there apple turnovers in the Wizard of Oz?” and found something that said “Apples were hurled at Dorothy and the scarecrow.”

                                                          I have watched the movie countless times and already knew this, but didn’t remember this fact or knew how apple turnovers tied in with the other two notes found in the book.

                                                          This is pretty much the only thing that has to do apple turnovers that was in the movie. I might be wrong, but it’s just to help understand the whole apple-turnover-thing.

                                                          • stef_stone

                                                            Hey everyone! Great ideas so far…
                                                            I’m pretty sure that the MGM/1939 stands for the production company/year of production (I googled it.)
                                                            Could VP Thornhill possibly be IT? He has had a lot of weird connections and control with this whole story.
                                                            Also, “Dot” is a common abbreviation for Dorothy. Could Nanna Dot be Dorothy from the Wizard of Oz?
                                                            Also, there are a lot of general connections between Amanda and Dorothy. Is Amanda trying to tell us that she is on a journey to try to get back home by referencing the Wizard of Oz?

                                                            • BlueRoseGrey

                                                              There very well COULD be an IT in Orion—but the question is WHO?! hmm…. GASP OMMAGEEZ!!!!!! okayokayokayokay…. so in A Wrinkle in Time… Meg’s father is missing. And Charles Wallace is the uber-de-duper smart brother. So lets think back to Amanda… Callie’s mother is missing. Amanda is uber-de-duper smart. And IT is the weird thing that captured Meg’s father, and at one point took control of CW.  Maybe Callie’s mother is captured? And maybe Amanda is in trouble, too? possibly? (Eh… i’m not sure about Amanda being in trouble… but… who knows?)

                                                              • BlueRoseGrey

                                                                o gosh i feel like an idiot. I posted my comment and then read everybody else’s… and a lot of it was the same (sorry!). And then with that Edward Lear thing… * smacks forehead * Dur-da-dur…

                                                                • BlueRoseGrey

                                                                  Okay… since this IS an envelope…. could there be a letter to go with it? And if there IS a letter… does that mean that these people were mailing it to somebody? Okay i know this might be a little far-fetched… But do you think that there might have been a person who people had turned to for advice, and they nicknamed him The Wizard of Oz? and this letter might have been a letter back to a person seeking advice… since there’s some sort of writing where the addresses would be. HMMMM…....

                                                                  • stef_stone

                                                                    That’s okay! That connection with the disappearance of Meg’s father and Callie’s mother is actually really significant. They were both working on big scientific discoveries, ones that probably would be censored by some people or that some people would not want released.
                                                                    Also, no big deal but its a postcard, not an envelope. Check out the previous stories, we kind of solved the mystery there. (The story with the postcard is a while back!) Anyways… that’s interesting about the return address. We could investigate that.

                                                                    • Jess☮❥

                                                                      BlueRoseGrey—It’s actually a postcard, but good guessing! : ]

                                                                      • AwesomeAnna93

                                                                        I haven’t read any of the above comments yet cause there is like 34 of them but
                                                                        The Wizard of Oz was filmed in 1939 at the MGM Studio in Culver City, CA.

                                                                        • fashionista17

                                                                          Hmm….... Good job AwesomeAnna93.

                                                                          • trumpetgirl

                                                                            I remembered we talked about Amanda’s 3 guides, and how Dorthey had 4 companions (Tin Man, Lion, and Scarecrow). Maybe Amanda is trying to say her life is heading towards something like the Wizard of Oz tale? She’s Dorthey (we talked about that also (see Amanda’s Yellow Brick Road)), and there’s a Wizard, and a wicked witch, etc etc. Maybe she even feels like Dorthey a little bit?

                                                                            Oh, by the way I agree with the MGM 1939, and didto on the good job AwesomeAnna.

                                                                            • BlueRoseGrey

                                                                              Oh right! Postcard! Sorry and thanks for the heads up!

                                                                              • AllieK

                                                                                Amanda’s traveled around a lot, maybe she feels like she’s lost and can’t find a place to call home?  Also, do you think A Wrinkle In Time and The Wizard of Oz can be compared?  I think the Wizard could be like IT.  They were both bodiless individuals that rule over their worlds.  With both we only see their true appearance for a short time; IT is really a bodiless brain but appears as the Man with Red Eyes and Charles and the Wizard appears to be a magical being when he’s really just an ordinary guy.  Just a thought I think that’s as far as the similarities go.

                                                                                • EllaMarie

                                                                                  Okay, maybe Callie’s mother has been captured…and Amanda has found out that Callie’s mother disappearing, (And she knows she means a lot to Callie) so she sets off to find her….somewhere. But if Callie’s mother was captured then, why did she send that note to Thorn? I don’t know…

                                                                                  • AlexInvisible

                                                                                    Maybe Amanda’s saying that you have to search for the IT in yourself? Seems a little far fetched, but that’s all I got from it.
                                                                                    Also, why did she sign her name with an M? Was she calling HERSELF Meg, perhaps? Saying that SHE was searching for something? Or that she was walking into a trap? Or that her father was missing?
                                                                                    Or, maybe Amanda didn’t write it at all. Maybe whoever “M” is could be someone Amanda wants us to investigate. Maybe “M” could be the person who helped Amanda paint the car…

                                                                                    • Jess☮❥

                                                                                      I think trumpetgirl is right. Dorothy had three companions, as Amanda has three guides.

                                                                                      • _Sakura_

                                                                                        I really like all the connections you made, guys! MGM is where the Wizard of Oz was filmed… so maybe it was sent from/to there? Well, SOMETHING happened there….


                                                                                        That’s all. this probably wasn’t much help… :P

                                                                                        • Schyler

                                                                                          Jess explained how everything could be linked to A Wrinkle In Time.Lets revisit that.
                                                                                          “Meg knew she had to search”:Callie,Nia,and Hal never once thought that they couldnt NOT search for Amanda.Like Meg Knew with her dad.the IT=in time part makes sense.so does everything else.I havent read alot of the comments above,but in the corner of the card it obviously is talking about the wizard of Oz.all youre missing is the z.What both the Wizard of oz and a wrinkle in time have in common?in both stories main charcters were in search of something.Dorothy,a way home and meg,her father.could it be that maybe these are both things that amanda is looking for?I own a copy of A Wrinkle in time and i could easily find specific parts of the book to see if there is anything to do with this card.

                                                                                          • suger_high

                                                                                            I thiink htat there will be an IT in Orion because Amanda probely went to every part of that town and planted clues while Hal, Callie and Nia wore not looking. then agian anything could happen in Orion even though no one notices.

                                                                                            • WhiteShadow

                                                                                              Oh I am an albino. But we do prefer to be called people with abinism

                                                                                              You must be logged in to see responses and contribute to the conversation.

                                                                                              Latest Responses

                                                                                              1. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                                                I like your idea a lot Niv! I read Shattered too, and your idea seems likely.. …

                                                                                              2. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                                                I think that the firefighters came in to hide stuff, like microphones to listen in to …

                                                                                              3. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                                                Okay, so now ANOTHER piece to the puzzle, but whats bothering me is that there are …

                                                                                              4. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                                                i have to say that this is probably a father-son situation. :I Or hey, maybe Stark …

                                                                                              5. Choose the Title for Book 4!!

                                                                                                I like Unlocked because of Amanda's key or Unraveled because they are unraveling the mystery!! :) …

                                                                                              Most Popular

                                                                                              1. Amanda's Yellow Brick Road

                                                                                              2. Cross my heart and hope to die…

                                                                                              3. Trickster Tagging

                                                                                              4. It's in the Cards, Or is it?

                                                                                              5. The Transatlantic Railroad

                                                                                              Subscribe to Our Stories

                                                                                              Be the first to know when discoveries are made!