When You Wish Upon A . . . Charm?

by Callie Leary on 03.26.2010

36 Responses

Like you guys, I have been pondering the question from last week. There are so many things that I could choose—like you guys did, AllieK’s stuffed wolf, Milana’s “summer,” Pipper’s bookshelf, Coupe’s crazy blonde curly hair—as metaphors, like my quilt or my planisphere, or even my annoying freckles and embarrassing blushing. They are mine, all mine.

As much as we agree with what you wrote LaurelQ, we do feel like we have to follow any leads we have about Amanda. So there I was following Susanna around Orion after school on my bike, like you guys said, to try to get to know her. It was my turn, Nia and Hal had other things to do that day. I saw Susanna coming out of a house with a flute tucked under her arm. It wasn’t in a case or anything, which I thought was kinda weird. I pulled up next to her on the sidewalk, bracing myself for accusations of being a stalker, but she actually looked happy to see me.

“Hey,” I said, smiling, hoping she would not wonder why I just happened to be standing outside this random house. Intent on distracting her, I nodded toward the instrument. “I didn’t know you were into the flute.”

I felt dumb as soon as I said it. I mean, of course I didn’t know Susanna was into the flute; I didn’t know much of anything about her. But she just shrugged and said, “Actually, I’m not. I pretty much hate the flute.”

I raised my eyebrows. “Yeah? So why do you play?”

Susanna sighed. “It was my older sister’s,” she explained. “She got it at a garage sale or something. That’s why it doesn’t have a case. Anyway . . . she left it when she went to college. My folks want me to have an extracurricular that we could afford, so they make me play. Mrs. Shipley’s a friend of my mom’s, and she gives me lessons for free.” She pulled the flute out from under her arm and gave it a dirty look. “But I hate having to play this thing just because my sister did. I already have to wear her old clothes. Everything I own is hand-me-downs. I wish, just for once, I could do something because I wanted to.”

Her monologue surprised me, and not just because that was the most I’d ever heard her say. But because I suddenly understood Amanda’s plan.

“If you could do anything,” I said, “what would it be?”

Susanna didn’t miss a beat. “Ride horses,” she said. “But horses and stables are crazy expensive,” she sighed, pretty much glaring at the flute.

When she said that, I totally understood why she made up those stories about her horse and her big house. She was kinda like a kid with an imaginary friend.

“Plus, the flute sounds lame, especially lately. It never sounded crystal clear, but for the last couple of weeks, it almost sounds like it has a cold or something. Figures I would have the most pathetic of used instruments, too . . . ”

She was twisting the flute back and forth in her hand, in total disdain, and as she did I noticed that her key charm kept hitting the instrument in the same spot, right over a little hole that seemed bigger than the rest and oddly shaped—almost keyhole-shaped. I grabbed Susanna’s wrist—”hey, what’s up,” she complained—and used the little key to pry open a tiny compartment in the old flute.

Inside: a little horse shoe charm. Amanda strikes again, right?

We sat together on the curb, staring at the flute and the collection of charms. Pretty dumbstruck.

“I think I know why Amanda gave you these,” I said. “You already had the bracelet, but now you have to fill it up. Make it your own. Fill it up with wishes, dreams, everything you want in life . And when you look at your charms, you’ll be reminded of all the things you’re going to do some day. You’ll be reminded of all the little dreams that make you Susanna.”

Susanna, fingering the necklace and the new charm, looked at the flute with new affection and nodded.

And I think Amanda wanted me to tell her that. I think Amanda wants all of us, but especially her guides, to pay attention to the people here with us now, and not lose sight of them while we search for who she is and try to discover the journey she’s on, like RRRules said. Helping other people was what Amanda was all about. And we think it’s a huge key to who she is and why this whole mystery started…

Who encourages YOUR deepest dreams?? YOUR heart’s desire??

36 responses

  1. trumpetgirl

    I try to encourage myself, but truly my Mom is my main helper in that catagory. She’s always complimenting me, and reminding me of the good qualities I have. I agree that helping people was Amanda’s main goals. If only there was some way to help Susanna fufill her dream to ride horses… I think that’s why Amanda has guides. They’re like helping elves, because she can’t be everywhere, helping everyone all the time. So Amanda goes to towns, helps her guides get going, and then leaves so they can continue helping people and making the world a better place.

    • dem_94

      I’m beginning to think that Amanda doesn’t want to found. We’ve all had that thought cross our minds lately, but now I just keep dwelling on it. I think she came to Orion and into our lives to show us how much of an impact we can have on others. By giving Susanna just three charms it brighten her day and made her smile. She wears that bracelet everyday now with newfound confidence. I’m not saying we should stop looking for her, but maybe we’ve been looking in the wrong places. I think by helping others in need it might led us closer to Amanda, and maybe even your mom Callie.

      • SarahB

        It suddenly makes sense to me. Amanda’s guides aren’t there to guide Amanda. They’re there to guide other people on Amanda’s behalf.

        That’s really neat, and you guys are really lucky. I love to help people out. It’s like a part of who I am. To have someone like Amanda helping you help others is just… awesome.

        • ♥MLE♥

          SarahB I agree with you. Amanda may no even trying to come back or to make us reallly go on a great adventrueous journey or something, she mights just be trying to help those who don’t know how to help themselves. Like take Callie for instance. She was in the IT group, but didn’t really belong, because of Amanda she now have Nia and Hal to hang out with and be friends. Maybe Susanna is being helped by Amanda to get enough money for riding lessons. Maybe not. But I think Amanda is trying to help the people who need help, but wont admit is because it will change the stable lives they have already. I try to do that to, just help people that need help. Its really satisfying to know you helped someone acheive a goal. I thinkt, that if Amanda is doing that, its the best thing for you to do.

          • RRRules

            I agree with dem. Amanda is sort of a thing of the past. She comes to help, and goes when she has. She doesn’t need to be found. I think that maybe the only mystery left is exactly _who_ she is.
            I try to encourage others a lot. As for myself, I find strength in the things around me and in what I hear. I just read a book and a character was talking to another character who tried to kill herself. She said, “Cowardice is dying. Living is bravery.” That is so true.
            The other day I was talking to Susanna. We went horseback riding and she seemed to be the happiest person in the world. It’s almost her birthday, but I’m gonna be out of town that day, so I gave her an early present. I know how to ride, so I gave her a brief lesson and we went for a ride on Crab Apple Hill. It was fun, and I think I’m finally getting into her shell that’s her personality and breaking it loose, freeing it to the world.

            • Squiggles

              It was really kind of Callie to say that to Susanna and cheer her up. It was a really nice thing to do.

              We should check who came into contact with Susannas flute that day, and the possible connections they had with Amanda. Also who else would have given Susanna a charm on behalf of Amanda.

              I think Amanda isn’t a thing of the past. She may need help as much as she is helping others, and also I R E A L L Y miss her. I can’t wait for us to find her!

              • AllieK

                I agree with SarahB and MLE.  I think the purpose of the guides is to help other people get the chance to express themselves and be who they want to be.  IDK if Amanda will come back eventually but she’s definitely trying to help those in need.

                • Pipper

                  FOr me, my BFF is my ideal, she’s free, she is her own person, and, but I think Susanna should just, not care about wat other people think about her, be her own person, get a REAL frend
                  a frend is a person who accepts you for who u are, not whu ur parents are or for how bg ur house is

                  • jessicahuey

                    A-MAN-DUH is she a man?

                    • BlueRoseGrey

                      For me, I suppose i’d have to say my mother—and my best friends. We’re all so close and alike—but so different, too. But its our differences that make us who we are. And I agree with Pipper on the whole “be your own person” thing for Susanna. I’ve always been for that. Be yourself.

                      • _Sakura_

                        I agree with RRRules. Amanda is from the past, and when her job is done, then she leaves and helps another person, or people.

                        I think the person who encourages me the most is me, my friends also encourage me sometimes. But if you want to be your own person, like Callie told Susanna, YOU have to encourage yourself. I encourage myself with the strength I can find, much like RRRules.

                        • 1Individual18

                          I encourage myself, but those who really help me are my friends and my brother.

                          • SarahB

                            I don’t think Amanda is gone for good… I mean, she’s still around leaving people stuff, right? If she was really never going to come back, then she’d have just left properly.

                            I think she probably has disappeared for a couple of reasons… partly because there is some trouble, some danger that we haven’t yet gotten to the bottom of (and I think it’s to do with Callie’s mom Ursula somehow) and partly because she knows that people learn lessons better if they come to understanding on their own. It’s one thing to tell someone “you have to help other people be better people when I’m not here to do it” but its another to come to the realisation yourself on your own.

                            • ummichan40

                              hmm…interesting but Amanda is most likely gonna leave Orion sometime i mean if she just stays there it might not be much of a story or anything. She has to travel and stuff too you know cuz if she really has some kind of deal with Nia’s mom,then she would have to meet her somewhere, no? And i doubt that Nia’s mom is gonna come back to Orion cuz what if someone sees her and recognizes her? Total dissaster!besides i think Ursula doesnt want her kind involved with what she’s doing but if it IS inevitable, then i think that she would be reluclant to she her daughter after all those years and explain something right there and then or something…

                              • justine

                                are you real!?

                                • jessicahuey

                                  I am real. Are you?

                                  • SarahB

                                    Um, yeah, last time I checked I was real… lol

                                    • jessicahuey

                                      lmao :)

                                      • trumpetgirl

                                        I agree with Sarah B, I don’t think Amanda is gone for good. I think she might be in some kind of danger, but how severe it is, I’m not completely sure. And I think it wouldn’t have had the same effect on the trio if they found out they were suppose to help people then if Amanda just straight out told them. And I’m fairly sure I’m real…...I think

                                        • JulietSteele

                                          I think we all need friends like Amanda to help us through life…maybe WHO Amanda is, isn’t so important. She’s bringing Callie, Hal and Nia closer together and helping people find themselves as well. Maybe Amanda’s an angel or something…rather than focusing on who she is and finding her, maybe Callie, Hal and Nia should be focusing on doing what Amanda does…helping people. They’ve got big shoes to fill.

                                          • Milana

                                            The entire theme of the Amanda Project has changed.  Instead of racing after every hint, clue, or mirage we might see, we’re getting philisophical.  What made us chase Amanda and try to find her in the first place?  What was it that made her so unusual?  Does it truly matter if we find her?

                                            Does she want to be found?
                                            Or does she want to be followed?

                                            • jessicahuey

                                              She wants to be found. goo theories everyone!

                                              • dimplefrances

                                                that was one nice story…

                                                • SerenaRules

                                                  My deepest dream is to become an author and for some to read my stories. They are all really good they just need love. Appericiation. But I am working on getting them published. But hten again who s going to take a 12 year olds writings very seriously

                                                  • dem_94

                                                    You shouldn’t give up SerenaRules. I’ve read books published by 13 year olds. You might get your start by being published in a school project. My engglish teacher is getting a book published with pieces from all of her classes.  A lot of people get their start in high school projects like that.

                                                    • SerenaRules

                                                      Thank you dem_94 Anyway Im starting to think that susanna’s horeshoe or key leads to somthing else another clue. Amanda is never simple. She is like a present. You have to unravel the wraping paper to find the prize.

                                                      • trumpetgirl

                                                        I agree. I think the coyote charm was so we would know Amanda was there. The other two charms might have a deeper meaning, or purpose..

                                                        • jessicahuey

                                                          think about waht the objects symbolize.

                                                          • lottie2020

                                                            i think the only thing in dreams if if you see a charm and then wish on it it will coem true

                                                            • trumpetgirl

                                                              Well [jessicahuey] a horseshoe in genral symbolizes luck, and a key is an object symbolic of opening and closing powers. It represents knowledge, mystery, initiation, and curiosity. But personally, I think the key was so we could open the flute. By giving Susanna the horseshoe charm, Amanda could be saying she [Susanna] was about to get lucky.

                                                              • stepit

                                                                I think she dosent want to get back. But when I think about it, I think that Amanda wants Nia, Hal, and Callie to all guide other people important to each of their lives! Like Callie maybe her mom, dador even the I-Girls. Or maybe they have to guide each other!

                                                                • B0rnAquarius

                                                                  Possibly the horseshoe leads to another charm. Maybe Susanna will find it while she is riding a horse.

                                                                  • jessicahuey

                                                                    peace out! >1Individual18> i agree with you that family influences the choices and decisions you make!! :) hehe

                                                                    • kbgirl

                                                                      Im so confused because Amand calls you guys her guides but it seems more like she is guiding you. Thats just a thought.

                                                                      • trumpetgirl

                                                                        Interesting thought! It does make sense. Maybe Amanda is guiding her “guides” to help guide others to do good things and be happier. (Yeah I know its kind of sappy but you know its just an idea!)

                                                                        • iwillfindaman

                                                                          yah!!!!!!!!!!!

                                                                          You must be logged in to see responses and contribute to the conversation.

                                                                          Latest Responses

                                                                          1. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                            I like your idea a lot Niv! I read Shattered too, and your idea seems likely.. …

                                                                          2. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                            I think that the firefighters came in to hide stuff, like microphones to listen in to …

                                                                          3. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                            Okay, so now ANOTHER piece to the puzzle, but whats bothering me is that there are …

                                                                          4. The Way He Looks Now

                                                                            i have to say that this is probably a father-son situation. :I Or hey, maybe Stark …

                                                                          5. Choose the Title for Book 4!!

                                                                            I like Unlocked because of Amanda's key or Unraveled because they are unraveling the mystery!! :) …

                                                                          Most Popular

                                                                          1. Amanda's Yellow Brick Road

                                                                          2. Cross my heart and hope to die…

                                                                          3. Trickster Tagging

                                                                          4. It's in the Cards, Or is it?

                                                                          5. The Transatlantic Railroad

                                                                          Subscribe to Our Stories

                                                                          Be the first to know when discoveries are made!